The Two Paths Of Jude And Dave

Turning point

Chapter Three: Turning Point

The house felt heavier after the funeral. Every sound—every creak, every sigh of wind—seemed to echo through the walls like a memory that refused to fade.

The twins’ father, Michael, had been laid to rest under an old oak tree on the edge of town. Only a handful of people attended: Clara, Jude, Dave, and a few neighbors who remembered the man before he lost himself.

Jude stood by the grave long after everyone had left. The dirt beneath his boots was still fresh, dark, and damp. He stared at the wooden cross, its shadow stretching across the ground like an unspoken reminder of everything he’d tried to forget.

“You still hate him?”

Jude turned to see Dave approaching. His brother’s face was calm, but his eyes carried the exhaustion of someone who had cried in silence.

“I don’t know,” Jude said, voice low. “Maybe I do. Maybe I don’t. What difference does it make now?”

Dave folded his arms. “It makes every difference. You’ve carried that hate for years. Now he’s gone, and it’s still here—eating you alive.”

Jude’s jaw tightened. “Don’t start preaching, Dave. You don’t understand what it was like.”

Dave stepped closer. “You think I don’t? I was there too, Jude. I saw everything—the shouting, the drinking, the nights Mom cried herself to sleep. But I decided not to let it turn me into him.”

Jude looked away. “Good for you.”

“Don’t do that,” Dave said sharply. “Don’t act like you never had a choice. You did. You still do.”

For a moment, neither spoke. The wind rustled through the trees, scattering a few leaves over the grave.

Then Jude whispered, almost to himself, “He told me not to waste my life hating him.”

Dave nodded slowly. “Then maybe, for once, you should listen to him.”

Jude’s laugh was hollow. “Too late for that.”

Dave’s voice softened. “It’s never too late, brother. The question is—what do you want to do with what’s left?”

Jude didn’t answer. He just stared at the grave until his eyes blurred and the world became one long, gray smear.

When they returned home, Clara was sitting in the living room, her hands folded around a cup of untouched tea. Her face looked years older, but her eyes still carried that quiet strength Jude had always ignored.

Dave sat beside her, placing a gentle hand on her shoulder. “You should rest, Mom.”

“I will,” she said faintly, though she didn’t move. “I just… keep thinking about all the years we lost to anger.”

Jude stood by the doorway, guilt pressing against his chest. He wanted to speak but couldn’t. He didn’t know how to apologize for something that felt like a lifetime of mistakes.

Later that night, after Dave had gone to bed, Jude found himself alone in the kitchen. The silence was deafening. He poured a glass of water and leaned against the counter, staring at the floor.

He could almost hear his father’s voice again—angry, bitter, drunk—but now it sounded… smaller. Sadder. Maybe even human.

For the first time, Jude wondered what had broken him. What pain had turned his father into a man who drowned himself in alcohol and rage?

Was he running from something, too?

The thought unsettled him. He set the glass down and rubbed his face, whispering to the empty room, “I don’t want to end up like him.”

The next morning, Jude woke early for the first time in months. The light filtered through the curtains, painting soft gold patterns across the walls.

He found Dave outside, sitting on the porch steps with a mug of coffee in hand.

“Couldn’t sleep either?” Jude asked.

Dave smiled faintly. “Not really. Too many memories in this place.”

They sat in silence for a while, listening to the distant sound of roosters and the hum of a world slowly waking.

“Remember when we used to race to the river before school?” Dave said, smiling. “You always won.”

Jude chuckled, surprising himself. “Yeah. I thought running away from everything made me faster.”

Dave looked at him thoughtfully. “Maybe it did. But you can’t outrun yourself forever.”

Jude sighed. “I know.”

Dave hesitated before asking, “What are you going to do now?”

Jude shrugged. “No idea. I messed up too many times. No job, no money, no plans. Just… regret.”

Dave set his mug down and looked him in the eye. “Then start small. Do one good thing today. Help Mom. Fix something. Just… start.”

Jude wanted to laugh at the simplicity of it, but something about Dave’s tone—gentle, steady, unshaken—made him pause.

Maybe it wasn’t about grand gestures. Maybe it really was about starting somewhere.

Over the following days, Jude began to move differently. He fixed the broken fence in the backyard. Repainted the front door. Helped Clara organize the old photographs that had gathered dust for years.

He didn’t say much, but each task brought a strange peace. A quiet sense that maybe, just maybe, redemption wasn’t a myth.

One afternoon, as he was repairing a leaky pipe, Clara appeared behind him with a small smile.

“You remind me of your father right now,” she said softly.

Jude froze, unsure how to take it.

“But,” she added, “you’re doing what he never did—trying.”

He swallowed hard. “I don’t know if trying is enough.”

“It’s more than giving up,” she said.

For the first time, Jude met her eyes without shame. “I’m sorry, Mom… for everything.”

She reached out, touching his cheek. “You’re my son. That’s enough.”

A week later, Dave prepared to return to the city. His train ticket sat on the kitchen table, beside a folded letter addressed to his mother.

“You sure you’ll be okay here?” he asked Jude as they walked to the station together.

Jude nodded. “Yeah. I think… I need to be here. To fix what I broke.”

Dave smiled, proud but cautious. “You’re serious this time?”

“I have to be,” Jude said. “I spent half my life blaming Dad. Now I just want to become someone Mom can be proud of.”

They reached the platform, the morning mist curling around their legs. The train’s whistle sounded in the distance.

Dave placed a hand on his brother’s shoulder. “You’ve always been strong, Jude. You just used it the wrong way. Now use it to build something good.”

Jude nodded, emotion thick in his throat. “I will. Thanks, Dave.”

As the train pulled away, Jude watched until it disappeared beyond the curve of the tracks. For the first time in years, he didn’t feel envy toward his brother—only gratitude.

That evening, Jude stood outside the house, watching the sunset bleed into the horizon. The sky burned with orange and violet, and for once, it didn’t make him feel small—it made him feel alive.

He took a deep breath and whispered to the fading light, “I’m not you, Dad. But I’ll do what you couldn’t—I’ll make this right.”

Inside the house, Clara hummed softly as she cooked dinner. The smell of stew drifted through the air, mingling with the sound of evening crickets.

And though the pain of the past still lingered, it no longer ruled him.

Jude wasn’t perfect—he still carried scars, doubts, and memories that hurt like fresh wounds—but now he also carried something else: the will to change.

---

Later that night, he sat by the window, writing in an old notebook he’d found in a drawer. His handwriting was rough, uneven, but his words were honest.

> “I used to think my father destroyed my life. But now I see—I was the one who kept the fire burning. He made his choices. I made mine.

Maybe the only way to forgive him is to finally forgive myself.”

He closed the notebook and leaned back, feeling a strange, fragile peace.

The moonlight slipped through the glass, casting a soft glow across his face. Somewhere far away, a train horn echoed into the night—a reminder of the road Dave had taken, and the one Jude was finally ready to walk.